Lyndon Johnson and Vance Hartke on 23 January 1964


Transcript

Edited by Kent B. Germany and Robert David Johnson, with Ashley Havard High and Patricia Dunn

See the daily introduction for 1964-01-23  [from the Norton edition]

For several days, Smathers had reported that Hartke had been irritated with the tax bill process. The particular issue here was his demand that musical instruments be exempted from excise taxes. Johnson chastised him for letting something that the President thought to be a petty local political issue interfere with the overall tax bill and the Democratic Party’s popularity.

President Johnson

Vance?[note 1] The Presidential Recordings Program revised the following section of text in 2021 for inclusion in The LBJ Telephone Tapes, a project produced by the Miller Center in partnership with the Lyndon B. Johnson Presidential Library to commemorate the library's 50th anniversary.

R. Vance Hartke

Yes, sir?

President Johnson

Can’t you help me on this excise tax thing? You’re going to wreck this damn bill. We’re not going to have any. And they’re going to get together this afternoon and try to make a motion to keep all excise taxes in there, and we need your help.

Hartke

Well, I mean—I suppose, that way started out—

President Johnson

I know it. And [Clinton P.] Clint Anderson [D–New Mexico] [unclear], they got all mad yesterday, because y’all screwed up that oil vote. And they’re after the oil companies, and [John J.] Williams [R–Maryland] and everything else. And those big oil companies oughtn’t to be raising hell [for] 40 million [dollars]. They got off with 400 million [dollars], and they ought to let y’all off the hook.

But, now, we’ve got it in a big screwed-up mess, and we—all of us are going down in defeat if we can’t operate any better than that. There’s no leadership in the committee, so, for God’s sakes, get in there. Clint Anderson says he’ll change, and you change, and get two or three more, and let’s . . .

Hartke

[Unclear] my—one big thing in there, one thing I wanted, was musical instruments.

President Johnson

Oh, well—

Hartke

This is—

President Johnson

—what’s important is the big credit to the Democratic Party, and let’s go on. The goddamned band and musical instruments—they won’t be talking about it next November.

Hartke

Well, they will in Elkhart [Indiana].[note 2] The Selmer Company had a major facility in Elkhart, Indiana—Hartke’s home state—that manufactured musical instruments.

President Johnson

What they’re going to be judging us by is—they’re going to be judging us whether we can pass a tax bill or not and whether we got prosperity. And if we haven’t, we’re going to—every day, it costs us 30 million [dollars] in our economy. [Unclear comment by Hartke.] So get in there and try to help me on this thing.

Hartke

OK, I'll . . . Can I save one vote out of there?

President Johnson

Well, we want to just have a general vote. One vote to put all the excises back. That’s the way we can get the majority of people [background voices speak] out of the bill.

Hartke

Yeah. Well, let me try to get that done. I’ll—

President Johnson

You do that and get ahold of Clint Anderson. And y'all go together. And see if you can’t do that for me.

Hartke

[Chuckles.] All right.

President Johnson

I’ll do something for you.

Hartke

I know you will.

President Johnson

Good-bye.

Hartke

All right. Bye.

President Johnson

Now, do it.[note 3] End of 2021 revisions.

Cite as

“Lyndon Johnson and Vance Hartke on 23 January 1964,” Tape WH6401.19, Citation #1492, Presidential Recordings Digital Edition [The Kennedy Assassination and the Transfer of Power, vol. 3, ed. Kent B. Germany and Robert David Johnson] (Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press, 2014–). URL: http://prde.upress.virginia.edu/conversations/9030220

Originally published in

Lyndon B. Johnson: The Kennedy Assassination and the Transfer of Power, November 1963–January 1964, ed. Kent B. Germany and Robert David Johnson, vol. 3 of The Presidential Recordings (New York and London: W. W. Norton and Company, 2005).